By Mike Ring, CEO — Blockchain Crypto Tax Prep
For most of crypto’s history, a lot of traders treated all their coins of the same type as one big pile. Bitcoin on Coinbase, Bitcoin on Kraken, Bitcoin on a Ledger: one pool of BTC, one running cost basis. Sell some anywhere, pull basis from the pile.
That approach ended on January 1, 2025. Since then, cost basis has to be tracked wallet by wallet and account by account. The IRS gave taxpayers a one-time way to make the switch, usually called the safe harbor for allocating unused basis. A lot of people never did anything with it, often because they never heard of it.
Here’s what it was, why it matters for your 2025 return and later years, and what to do if you never allocated.
What changed
Cost basis is what you paid for an asset. When you sell, your gain or loss is the sale price minus the basis of the specific units you sold.
Under the per-wallet approach, the units you sell from a given wallet or exchange account have to come from that wallet’s own basis. If you sell ETH on Kraken, the basis has to be from ETH you actually hold on Kraken, not ETH you bought on Coinbase that never moved.
Say you bought 1 ETH on Coinbase years ago for $300 and 1 ETH on Kraken in 2024 for $3,500, and in 2025 you sold the Kraken ETH. Under the old pooled habit, you might have picked whichever basis looked best. Under the per-wallet approach, the sale on Kraken uses the Kraken coin’s basis.
What the safe harbor was
When the rules changed, most people had years of pooled history. Their records didn’t say which basis belonged to which wallet. The IRS provided a transition so taxpayers could assign their existing, unused basis to the wallets and accounts where their coins actually sat as of the start of 2025. That transition is Rev. Proc. 2024-28, a one-time safe harbor for moving from one big pool of basis to wallet-by-wallet tracking, which took effect on January 1, 2025.
In plain terms, it let you take the basis you already had and allocate it across your holdings, once, under a consistent approach. Two approaches were allowed: a specific-unit allocation, where you assign basis to particular units, or a global allocation, where you set one consistent rule and apply it across all your wallets and accounts.
There were timing and documentation requirements attached. A global-allocation rule had to be in place before January 1, 2025. A specific-unit allocation had to be finished by the earlier of your first sale or transfer in 2025 or the due date of your 2025 return, including extensions. Either way it had to be documented, and once made it can’t be changed.
Why so many people missed it
- It arrived quietly. It was guidance, not a new form, and most consumer tax software didn’t make a point of it.
- It landed alongside the 1099-DA rollout, which took up most of the attention in 2025.
- It required records many people didn’t have: a clean picture of what they held, where, and what they paid for it, as of a specific date.
- Pooled tracking was the default in a lot of tools for years, so nothing looked wrong until the rules changed under it.
Why it matters now
For your 2025 return. Every sale in 2025 needs a basis that can be traced to the wallet or account it came from. If your records are still pooled, the basis on your return may not hold up if anyone asks how it was calculated.
For every year after. Basis carries forward. Whatever starting point you used for each wallet on January 1, 2025 is the foundation for every future sale from that wallet. An undocumented starting point is a problem that compounds.
For broker forms. Exchanges report proceeds on Form 1099-DA, and over time more basis information will show up on those forms too. If your own records use a different basis than the broker’s, you need to be able to explain the difference. See why your 1099-DA may show missing cost basis.
If you never allocated
You’re in a big group, and it’s fixable in the sense that the records can be rebuilt. What options remain depends on the rules and your timing. The safe harbor window has closed. From 2025 on, basis is tracked wallet by wallet using your actual records, with first-in, first-out (FIFO) applying within each wallet unless you use specific identification. How that plays out for your own history is worth working through with a tax professional.
Whatever the answer is for your situation, it rests on the same foundation:
What to gather
- Full transaction history from every exchange you’ve ever used, including closed accounts. Export CSVs covering your entire history, not just recent years.
- Every wallet address you control (hardware, browser and mobile wallets), with their on-chain history.
- What you held, where, as of January 1, 2025. Balances per wallet and per exchange account for each asset.
- Your purchase records, so each unit’s basis can be traced to a real acquisition.
- Transfers between your own wallets. These aren’t sales, but they move basis from one place to another, and they’re where pooled records most often break.
- Any past returns and the method your software used, so the new records can be reconciled to what you already filed.
Next steps
- Pull the records above before exchanges purge old data or accounts get harder to access.
- Figure out where every coin was on January 1, 2025, and what basis belongs to it.
- Check your 2025 sales against wallet-level basis, not pooled basis.
- Talk to a professional about which approach fits your situation and how to document it.
This is the work we do: reconciling multi-exchange, multi-wallet histories down to the wallet level, with every figure traceable to a transaction. If you want help, book a free 30-minute consult or call 410-216-4632.
This post is general information, not tax advice. Your situation may differ. Talk to a qualified tax professional before you file.
Need help with your crypto taxes? Mike Ring and the BCTP team handle the messy stuff — multi-chain DeFi, 1099-DAs that don’t add up, prior-year amendments. Free consult at cryptotaxprep.io or call 410-216-4632.
This isn’t tax advice. Talk to a professional about your specific situation.